Not as good as My Sisters Keeper, but I still really liked it.At times it did feel like she was adding in plot points simply for shock factor while not imagining them as true parts of the story - as if this book was more like a soap on tv. I felt this weakened the feel overall - it broke my involvement with the characters as I had to pause to scoff or roll my eyes (not literally, thankfully) but...It's something light to read, it provided entertainment, and I guess that's all she was trying for.